Ripe: The Rise, Fall and Future of Insurtech

The insurtech landscape has transformed dramatically over the past decade, from an investor-fueled frenzy of startups to a more measured ecosystem where only businesses with genuine market differentiation survive.

While many early players struggled, those combining technological agility with deep insurance expertise have created sustainable models. As artificial intelligence heralds the next potential wave of disruption, the industry stands at another critical juncture.

Insurtech Digital speaks exclusively with David Rowntree, Chief Underwriting Officer at Ripe, who shares his insights on what separated the winners from the losers and what aspiring insurtechs must learn from the past to thrive in the future.

How has insurtech changed in the last 10 years? 

A decade ago, insurtech startups were fated as the future of insurance, promising to revolutionise the industry. These fledgeling companies excited the market with bold ambitions, leveraging technology to streamline and disrupt the insurance sector.

Investors poured billions into such projects, eager to back the next big thing. The new excitement seemed as if insurtech would completely reshape the landscape. 

However, a decade on and many of these ambitious ventures have struggled to deliver on their initial promise.

The term 'insurtech' now carries a more sobering legacy - a reminder that innovation alone isn't enough to guarantee success. And while a few insurtechs have thrived, many startups underestimated the challenges of operating in the insurance sector. 

So, what separates the successful insurtechs from those that struggled? The answer lies in understanding both the unique challenges of the sector and what it truly takes to build a sustainable insurance business.

Why do insurtechs fail?

Many founders were first and foremost tech entrepreneurs, and insurance professionals second - if at all.

While technology certainly plays a pivotal role in insurance, it doesn’t replace the deep knowledge needed to manage risk effectively. Without this expertise, insurtechs struggled to balance customer needs and risk management. 

Building any startup is challenging, and insurtechs add another level of complication. Insurance is a highly regulated and complex industry where even established insurers sometimes struggle with technical changes. 

Legacy insurers are often 'held together by glue and string' after years of mergers and acquisitions. With most of their IT budget consumed by maintaining these complex systems, they struggle to invest in innovation.

This complexity, along with the need for deep sector knowledge and strong risk management, creates a challenging environment that many startups underestimated.

A final critical mistake made by many insurtechs was assuming they could simply replicate successful models from other markets and sectors.

Understanding the competitive environment isn't just about knowing your direct competitors - it's about truly grasping the market dynamics and identifying what space your business will thrive in.

Why is it important insurtechs have a ‘right to exist’?

Successful insurtechs aren't just technologically advanced, they have a clear 'right to exist' in their chosen markets.

This means being the best at something – whether from superior data insights enabling better pricing, exceptional service delivery, or the ability to efficiently serve market segments that larger insurers struggle to reach due to their legacy infrastructure constraints.

The UK insurance market presents unique opportunities for insurtechs.

With a vast majority of consumers comfortable buying insurance online (only 7% of Britons prefer purchasing insurance in physical shops), and a sophisticated price comparison infrastructure, digital distribution is well-established.

However, this also means that insurtechs need to find genuine gaps in the market rather than simply offering digital versions of existing products.

While established insurers struggle with expensive legacy systems, insurtechs have the advantage of building their tech solutions from scratch and platforming their acquisitions.

However, this technological advantage alone isn't enough - successful insurtechs must combine this agility with deep insurance expertise and market understanding.

How do you build an established, tech-led insurance business? 

Of the many insurtech startups that emerged during the industry's ‘hype’ phase, the ones that still exist today all have something in common – they operate with a sustainable approach to growth.

Instead of pursuing disruption for its own sake, these success stories prioritised a sensible tech adoption to boost efficiency, enhance the customer experience and scale the business strategically.

Successful insurtechs gain a competitive edge with superior data insights and accurate risk pricing. Their data-driven approach and efficient digital distribution allow them to profitably serve niche markets that traditional insurers find challenging.

For example, at Ripe we identified a niche market and developed a tailored golf insurance product specifically for golfers.

Though the company pre-dates the full swing of the insurtech hype, this approach to insurance technology, developing a USP, allowed Ripe to scale successfully.

Broadly, the insurtechs that will continue to succeed are those that prioritise a well-defined market over hype-driven expansion.

What does the future hold for insurtechs?

As the technological disruptions of the 2010s recede into history, a select group of digital insurance companies have demonstrated their enduring value and continue to operate successfully. 

Today, as artificial intelligence ushers in another wave of disruption, the industry once again is at a critical juncture. One of the advantages insurtechs have over legacy insurers is freedom from outdated systems.

As they are not held back by legacy infrastructure, they are free to adapt quickly, incorporating new technologies such as AI effectively.

The question will be whether this will lead to a new bubble of insurtechs – and crucially, if the upcoming cohort of insurance startups learn from the mistakes of its predecessors.

The future of insurtech belongs to businesses that combine technological agility with deep insurance expertise - those that understand their market, know their competitive advantage, and build sustainable operations rather than chasing rapid expansion.

In an industry where even small technical changes can be challenging for established players, the opportunity remains for focused, well-executed insurtech ventures to thrive.

Make sure you check out the latest industry news and insights at InsurTech and be part of the conversation at our global conference series, FinTech LIVE.

Discover all our upcoming events and secure your tickets today.

InsurTech is a BizClik brand